Hello Giles,
just another comment before I have to leave: Actually the aim of the course is to give all the PADI Instructors a good toolset, so they can really teach the course properly and make the students investment worthwile. I found that many instructors felt unconfortable teaching the “classic PADI photo specialty”, because if you were not 100% into photography the course might not have been what you expected from it. I agree to your critique there, but also I would like to emphasize my personal view on this:
I think we need to get as many people into digital underwater photography as possible! That way, we are able to kick the message of the ocean out of the water and let our non-diving friends and families know what is out there to see - and worth protecting! That was my ethical motivation behind the course.
I admit, that I have never shot film or topside and managed to learn digital underwater photography within only two/three years to get published in magazines. The course materials and your PADI Instructor should help you to ride that (already steep) learning curve within days. It simply helps you to get around doing everything by trial and error on your own. I found that PADI does a very good job in teaching people essential things within a short time. Therefore I thought that it is the right partner for this photo course, that completely follows PADIs magic receipe.
To come back to your eye surgery example: I think that it is, completely opposite! With a well designed PADI course that is properly executed to the standards you can even make a chimpanse diving. It should not matter who actually gives you the course because the materials should always help you as an instructor to properly re-produce it. That is what amazed me about the system from the first minute on and what I always wanted to do different for my own photo course:
MAKING IT EASY FOR PEOPLE TO LEARN UNDERWATER PHOTOGRAPHY.
The old “Here is the pro”, there is the “poor student” and delays until you got the results from your film camera always blocked the breakthrough of a photo course because many things were up to a skilled Instructor. I hope that this course launch and the upcoming success changes the attidude I have observed so many times in this small industry.
People can learn a lot about their digital camera within a short time and come back with even much better images. After that they might turn into artists or just technical shooters for documenting reef life. In fact I’d love to have as many Instructors out there teaching the program and making themselves comfortable with the course materials. They might find out that underwater photography (in the digital age) is not as complicated as they thought and that they might start teaching it.
:wink: Andi